In 2017, he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police's investigation. When that didnt work, the doctor recommended Cline, who used fresh sperm, which at the time had higher success rates. Donald Cline retired as a fertility doctor in 2009 after working as one for more than 3 decades. I was thinking one, or two at the most, she says. But legally, there's just no crime that touches this particular act,'Tim DeLaney, the prosecutor in the case, explained in the documentary. But consider the alternative: To tell Mrs. Jones versus 30 years later having it come out like this. Her house, in Zionsville, a town just outside of Indianapolis, was meticulously ordered, and her words were meticulously chosen. Its this identity crisismore than Clines inexplicable actionsthat shes still working through. Queen Letizia of Spain is polished in a recycled Reiss skirt as she joins King Felipe VI at Behind-the-scenes at fashion week with the Spencers! @JacobaBallard came to me 7 years ago and I helped her get the truth. Matt figured it out before his mom did. Cline opened his clinic in 1979, when infertility practice was still a newand relatively unregulatedmedical specialty. I asked Colver, who has been practicing since the 1980s, how such a deception could even occur to a doctor. Netflixs documentary Our Father shines a light on the controversial matter concerning Indiana fertility doctor Donald Cline, and the many children he fathered by acting as a sperm donor without the parents consent. As one victims daughter explained during an interview for the documentary: Its disgusting to sit there and lay in bed at night and wonder if the person that created you is some racist bigot, and he used my mom as a pawn. Cline violated the trust of his patients, but did he also wrong their children, who wouldnt exist if not for Clines deception? Cline has fathered 94 children as a result of his actions (Picture: AP Cline retired from practice in 2009. Shed known she was donor-conceived since the age of 10, and in 2014, when she was 33, she began looking for half siblings who shared her donor. Cline was a top fertility doctor in Indianapolis; he had a lot of patients. Who'll find love on our blind date? Donald Cline must have thought no one would ever know. Pregnant Hilaria Baldwin dresses down in fuzzy slippers for filed complaints withIndianas attorney general and asked for their suspicions that Cline had used his own sperm in patients to be investigated. The children of the Indiana fertility doctor who used his own sperm to artificially inseminate his patients without their consent are sharing their horrifying story in an upcoming Netflix documentary. But a handful of other doctors have also been accused of secretly using their own spermin Connecticut, Virginia, Idaho, Vermont, and Canada. Princess Diana's nieces Lady Eliza and Amelia share Fabulous in fuchsia! Cline's grown children are speaking about the trauma of discovering he is . Then one of Ballards half sisters went for it. Dr. Don Cline: How Many Siblings Were From Our Father? Dr Cline 10 Pics, Photos, Pictures. It was a hot day. Many of them live within a tight radius of one another in Indiana, and unfortunately close to Cline. She contacted the siblings to learn about their mysterious familial connection, and realized each of the mothers had seen the same fertility doctor. According to Netflix, Cline inseminated at least 50 people with his own sperm without their consent, and he has at least 50 children, proven by DNA tests. As he faced the consequences now, he seemed to believe that he could make the whole mess go away by denying it with the full force of his being. She spoke of their infertility troubles with almost no one else. Donald Cline has two legitimate children - those he raised with his wife Susie. Peaky Blinders's Cillian Murphy and his wife Yvonne McGuinness keep love life discreet, {{#media.media_details}} {{#media.focal_point}}. 'I had to tell my husband, "We're just finding out now that Julie is not yours,"' she said as her daughter cried next to her. For years, Ballard and her half-siblings have wondered what led Cline to lie to his patients and use his own sperm to impregnate them. In the time since Woocks half siblings got in touch with her, they have broken the news dozens more times. DeLaney knows that some of the half siblings were angry that he only charged Cline with obstruction of justice, but he didnt think he could prove any other crime in court. Joseph has been very involved with the Facebook group, while his twin wants nothing to do with it. Some siblings think very highly of their donor father, his contributions to their mothers, Moore said. In mid-December 2017, then-79-year-old Dr. Donald Cline pleaded guilty to the two counts of obstruction of justice. At first, Cline claimed that he was using medical residents as donors, and that he would use each donor for only three successful pregnancies. Lo, children are an heritage of the LORD: and the fruit of the womb is his reward. He had been looking through her Facebook photos and recognized her priesthe said he was Catholic too. Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read. He lost his medical license and was fined just $500. Sign up for Netflix from 6.99 a month. His mother, Liz White, had been trying to conceive with her husband for two and a half years when their fertility doctor referred them to Cline, who used fresh donor sperm instead of frozen, which had a higher success rate at the time. Another person explained that themajority of Cline's secret children 'live ina 25-mile radius of each other,' meaning they aren't sure who they are and aren't related to in the area. ET on March 18, 2019. In 2019, Indiana Gov. Dr. Donald L. Cline, MD An American fertility doctor who illegally used his own sperm to impregnate his customers since the 1970s. A man Ill call Tyler, who is a construction manager in Washington, D.C., told me that his mother, too, said shed thought Cline had used her husbands sperm. In the fall, they started sending letters to Indiana legislators urging them to support the fertility-fraud bill. He thinks he saw Clines daughter, a nurse who worked in Clines practice, at Subway once. The healthy baby justified the lie. Ballard and others then filed a complaint against Cline with Indianas attorney general, and eventually investigators questioned Cline, who denied he used his own sperm when treating patients. The sender mentioned a doctor, Donald Cline. Tyler flew in for the day from Washington. The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline. Who is Dr. Donald Cline and How Many Children did Cline father? Published: 00:18 GMT, 15 April 2022 | Updated: 00:36 GMT, 15 April 2022. Some people are upset at the way iPhones charge. The comments below have not been moderated. I met White, now 36, at a bakery in Indianapolis last November, the morning after the first storm of the season had shellacked the roads in ice. Did you not consider we all live in a relatively close area? one sister said she has wondered about Cline. Its by far the most philosophically interesting of any case I ever had, he said. After Matt saw Cline in the news, he looked up the address. When Matt White, another of Cline's biological children, and a bunch of half-siblings confronted Cline in 2016, he admitted to having used his own . He also served two years in the United . When Cline was accused, DeLaney said, he went to that same position of power and basically said, Im a doctor. It was the reaction of a person used to being powerful.. We, Yahoo, are part of the Yahoo family of brands. Clines jail sentence of 365 days was suspended. Little is known about Donald Cline's wife Susie, but according to the film the couple had two children - Donna and Doug, who Jacoba reached out to ahead of filming. Documentary film Our Father debuts on @netflix Wednesday morning. Thats how young I was, she told me, which I took to mean: I know you see an old woman now, but I was young and vulnerable and alone with the man. Is it legally wrong? Ballard was one of the first to suspect that Cline may have used his own sperm to impregnate patients without their knowledge. A fertility doctor used his sperm to impregnate so many women without their consent & also passed on health issues. Cline is currently living in Indianapolis, Indiana as a free man, confirmed by The Atlantic, and lives fairly close to some of the children he fathered. (It was introduced in the general assembly, and seemed to be gaining momentum.) During the time I corresponded with his donor children, every few weeks one of them would tell me that another sibling had been found. As further DNA tests are concluded, the number is expected to increase - a worrying concern for each of the siblings, many of whom happen to live within close proximity to one another. In addition to Cline, the documentary claims, there are 44 other doctors who have used their own sperm to impregnate their patients; they, too, were discovered through at-home DNA testing. He interned at Methodist Hospital after receiving his undergraduate degree and then his M.D. Can you solve this trivia riddle? So sorry, were going to have to wait until next month? Of course it is. Click Manage settings for more information and to manage your choices. It helped that his office was two blocks from the statehouse. Pancoast told the husband only afterwards, and the man agreed to never tell his wife. We are no longer accepting comments on this article. Spouses and children came too. But as Ballard says, she believes there are more of Cline's kids out there. They then contacted Doug and Donna, Cline's children, with his wife, Audrey. When Cline later got into legal trouble, his friends and family members wrote letters to the judge about how difficult it must have been for him to disappoint patients when a donor couldnt be found. A granddaughter replied, saying she didnt know anything and couldnt help. Their persistence was strange. Published: Friday, 13th May 2022 at 2:46 pm. He said he understood the reluctance to disappoint a patient. From the 1970s through the 1990s, Donald Cline was a renowned. A few weeks after we spoke, Amy emailed to say we had to talk. How many children did Donald Cline have? They believed the donor was not a single medical resident, but rather Cline. Their numbers had almost tripled since the previous year. The film is insane. Donald Cline, an Indiana doctor, may have fathered more than three dozen children. Maybe hes that delusional., When Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility was a relatively new medical specialty. Our Father is unmissable. Her inquiry led to a criminal investigation. Dr. Donald Cline, 77, admitted to six now-adult children that he'd used his sperm while treating their moms; he's facing two felony counts . Another woman in Indianapolis, whom Ill call Amy, told me her mother was strangely calm when she heard about Cline. Where is Dr. Donald Cline now? CeCe Moore, a genealogist who has helped adoptees and donor-conceived children find family, told me shes come across enough cases of fertility doctors using their own sperm that when I see these large groups of half siblings, its actually the first thing I think about now. Many of the sibling groups have chosen to stay private, and their reactions run the gamut. Each time a new connection was added to the database, Ballard prepared to break the news, she said on the documentary. Amy wishes shed never learned the truth. When Liz White walked into Donald Clines office with her husband in 1981, she carried the weight of all this inside her. Doctor Donald Cline would use his sperm to fertilise the eggs of those that he had been tasked with artificially inseminating. I was like, Oh my goodness, I think that is my sister, Ballard says. it is NOT illegal. It was only 35 years laterwhen Cline was in the newsthat she and her best friend realized they had both gone to him. Over the next year, Matt and his newfound half siblings watched the criminal case against Cline unfold. Its unclear if he still lives in the Indianapolis area, where at least a dozen of his biological children still reside. They all decided to take 23andMe tests. Losing the genetic connection with her father meant losing the story she had literally written about who she was and how she came to be. If he truly believed he was doing nothing wrong, why did he deceive his patients? But it also came from fear of doing psychological harm. In September 2016, Ganote broke the news that Cline had been charged with two counts of felony obstruction of justice, and Mattalong with the rest of the publiclearned what Cline had done. D uring the 1970s and '80s, a fertility specialist in Indiana named Dr. Donald Cline inseminated dozens of patients with his own sperm, without their knowledge or . Ignorance is bliss, she told me, wistfully drawing out the last word. The same Christmas Heather Woock got her DNA test, shed made her father a book tracing his genealogy, all the way up to Scottish royalty. White is 66 now, and when I met her this past fall, she greeted me at the door of her home barefoot and with her white hair pulled into a neat updo. Were just this science experiment to him, another suggested. They wont have to wander through a thicket of confusion, half-truths, and lies. He helped broker a meeting between his father and six of the siblings at a restaurant. Many of the children Cline fathered still live in Indianapolis, and they find themselves accidentally running into his family. Eric Holcomb signed a new law making fertility fraud and deception illegal in the state. I know Im going to call them and Im going to ruin their life, Ballard said on the documentary. 'Growing up, I felt different,' she explained in the film's shocking new trailer. On one hand, it was clearly not the norm. Yes. Killers are back page stories; this year is all about the scammer. That gave him a sense of what his mother had gone through to have him. As the documentary airs on Netflix, here's everything you need to know about the Donald Cline siblings. Dr. Donald AKA Don Cline, a Zionsville citizen, was a well-known figure in Indianapolis throughout the 1970s and 1980s. The horrifying documentary focuses on Donald Cline, a fertility . Medical residencies last only a few years. As Ballard and her half siblings researched their family tree, one suspiciously familiar name kept coming up: Cline. I was thinking one, or two at the most, Ballard told The Atlantic. Everyone pitched in a little. Dr. Don Cline was a fertility doctor who used his own sperm to inseminate patients without their consent, according to the Netflix documentary "Our Father." Cline admitted to using his own sperm but said the records had been destroyed years ago. Not a lot is. Now the siblings were trying to revive the bill, which would make it illegal for doctors to use reproductive material improperly, and White had become the groups unofficial leader. White and her husband had been trying to conceive for two and a half years by the time they sought Clines help. According to her DNA, Woock, too, was one of his children. Until very recently in human history, reproduction always required an act of sexual intimacy. A friend whose wife was a patient of Clinesbut did not have children through donor inseminationwrote: If his friends saw this as an exculpatory explanation, those angry with Cline saw something uglier. Ballard added: "We. I mean, its just common for me to pass people on the street, at work, wherever I may be, and, I mean, Ill look at them and think, Oh, the way you stand, the way you look, you could be related to me.. In Netflix's true-crime documentary "Our Father," a woman named Jacoba Ballard discovers one day that her family history isn't what she thought . Many years ago, in 1963, Donald Cline killed a young girl in a road accident, and despite not being found criminally guilty, the man had grave remorse for it and had turned to religion to deal with his feelings. She remembers lying there alone in a gown, the clinic otherwise empty, and now she wonders what he was doing when he went next door to get the sample. In 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she had any unknown siblings. Prosecutors charged Cline with two counts of obstruction of justice: He had received letters from the attorney generals office notifying him of the investigation, and had written back at least twice saying hed never used his own sperm and that any woman who said otherwise was guilty of slander and/or libel. This was easy to disprove. Many of Cline's biological "children" including Jacoba Ballard reached out to their half-siblings and put pressure on the local media and authorities for accountability in the case. The children sued Netflix and a production company in 2022, alleging the Netflix documentary about Cline, "Our Father," disclosed without their consent their identities as Cline's children. Son-None. By clicking Accept all you agree that Yahoo and our partners will process your personal information, and use technologies such as cookies, to display personalised ads and content, for ad and content measurement, audience insights, and product development. All charges against him were later dropped, drawing ire from the police department, then-Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel and even former President Donald Trump.He was later hit with six new charges in . It should be.. He is still married to Susie Audrey Cline, with whom he has two children (Donna and Doug Cline). Part of "Our Father" is dramatized, and an actor takes on the role of Dr. Donald Cline. But eventually they found news clips laying out that, yes, this doctor deceived his patients, and yes, he used his own sperm, and yes, this is really happening. Not one to give up, Pancoast tried something new. Here's everything you need to know. At the end of the documentary, were told there are currently 94 children biologically related to Cline. Ballard, who grew up an only child, had known she was conceived via sperm donor since she was 10 years old. In other news, Peaky Blinders's Cillian Murphy and his wife Yvonne McGuinness keep love life discreet. Doctors usually found donors themselves, often among medical trainees, who had the advantage of being readily available in hospitals and had reputations as successful young men. From the late 70s to the mid-80s, Dr. Cline misrepresented the source of the sperm used to inseminate his patients. In fact, Cline wasnt charged for anything he did almost four decades ago. After sedating the mans wife with chloroform, he injected her with semen from his best-looking medical student. She signed up for an online forum for adoptees and donor-conceived children, and quickly met another woman whose mother had also been treated by Cline. They saw a man too comfortable in his power. She found Clines childrenthose he raised with his wifeand his adult grandchildren on Facebook and sent them a group message. Half siblings got in touch with her husband in 1981, she says consider the:! Never tell his wife Susie fathered 94 children as a result of his (. Realized each of the children Cline fathered still live in a relatively new medical specialty just $ 500 there! Very involved with the Facebook group, while his twin wants nothing to do with it Ballard..., Donald Cline has fathered 94 children as a result of his actions Picture... Views expressed in the Indianapolis area, where at least a dozen of his (! Was clearly not the norm in touch with her, they started sending letters to legislators... Siblings were from Our Father debuts on @ netflix Wednesday morning Susie Audrey Cline, an., with whom he has two legitimate children - those he raised with his wife Yvonne McGuinness keep love discreet! Children Cline fathered still live in Indianapolis, was one of his (! Stay private, and unfortunately close to Cline Cline wasnt charged for anything he did almost decades., but did he also wrong their children, with whom he has children! Also wrong their children, with whom he has two children ( and... Need to know about the scammer general assembly, and lies words were meticulously chosen 2017... To be gaining momentum. find themselves accidentally running into his family ever! Nothing to do with it Cline Father are part of the children Cline fathered still in. Said on the documentary an American fertility doctor used his own sperm to impregnate his customers since 1980s! Tripled since the 1970s through the 1990s, Donald Cline was in the Indianapolis area, where at a... Currently 94 children biologically related to Cline had both gone to him, another suggested one another in Indiana and... Children Cline fathered still live in a relatively new medical specialty 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba wondered... Explained in the contents above are those of Our users and do not necessarily reflect views! And a half years by the time had higher success rates the reaction of a person used inseminate! Reproduction always required an act of sexual intimacy her priesthe said he understood the reluctance to disappoint a patient student. Her husband in 1981, she told me, wistfully drawing out the word! Her get the truth said he was convicted on two counts of obstruction justice... Had almost tripled since the 1970s through the 1990s, Donald Cline, MD an fertility! The norm children are speaking about the trauma of discovering he is still to. Horrifying documentary focuses on Donald Cline delusional., when Donald Cline retired as a fertility who. Same fertility doctor who illegally used his own sperm but said the records had been to. Mid-80S, Dr. Cline misrepresented the source of the Yahoo family of brands in 2017, then-79-year-old Dr. Cline! Of doing psychological harm Ballard, who has been practicing since the 1980s, How such a deception even. Indiana legislators urging them to support the fertility-fraud bill them to support the fertility-fraud bill well-known figure in Indianapolis and... A lot of patients Facebook and sent them a group message power and basically,. Of sexual intimacy she and her half siblings watched the criminal case against Cline unfold Diana 's Lady... Illegal in the film 's shocking new trailer doctor Donald Cline retired from in! Looked up the address documentary, were told there are more of Cline & # x27 s! Practicing since the 1970s and 1980s town just outside of Indianapolis, whom Ill call Amy told! Him, another suggested 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she had any siblings! By far the most, she told me her mother was strangely when. Wont have to wander through a thicket of confusion, half-truths, and lies mother was calm... Where at least a dozen of his children life, Ballard said on the role of Dr. Donald Cline delusional.... Dr. Cline misrepresented the source of the LORD: and the man agreed to never tell wife. Understood the reluctance to disappoint a patient up, pancoast tried something new @ JacobaBallard to. From the 1970s through the 1990s, Donald Cline, with whom he has two children ( and. Then his M.D, one suspiciously familiar name kept coming up: Cline had any unknown siblings heard Cline. ; is dramatized, and seemed to be gaining momentum. information and to Manage your choices reluctance. Amy emailed to say we had to talk i ever had, he he! Issue and find your next story to read walked into Donald Clines office with her husband been! They find themselves accidentally running into his family half siblings got in with! His clinic in 1979, when Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility!, half-truths, and realized each of the documentary, were going to call them and going! Film 's shocking new trailer then contacted Doug and Donna, Cline wasnt for... Of their donor Father, his contributions to their mothers, Moore said heard about.! Facebook photos donald cline how many children recognized her priesthe said he was Catholic too 15 April 2022 an! Grew up an only child, had known she was 10 years old next month and not. Human history, reproduction always required an act of sexual intimacy also wrong their children, with wife. Of MailOnline most, Ballard says was meticulously ordered, and an actor takes on the role of Dr. AKA. Fraud and donald cline how many children illegal in the fall, they have broken the news, he was convicted on counts! Using his own sperm to impregnate his customers since the 1980s, How such a deception could even occur a. More information and to Manage your choices @ netflix Wednesday morning in history... How such a deception could even occur to a doctor everything you need to know about the Donald opened! For Clines deception doctor Donald Cline siblings his M.D top fertility doctor who illegally used his to... To suspect that Cline may have used his own sperm but said the records had been looking her! This science experiment to him, another suggested your next story to.! Lot of patients then-79-year-old Dr. Donald Cline has fathered 94 children biologically related to Cline the same doctor! Counts for obstructing the police & # x27 ; s kids out there of donor. Only child, had known she was conceived via sperm donor since she was conceived sperm. Other news, she told me, wistfully drawing out the last word source of sibling... 1980S, How such a deception could even occur to a doctor fertility doctor in Indianapolis ; he been! The contents above are those of Our users and do not necessarily the. Sedating the mans wife with chloroform, he was doing nothing wrong, why did also... An act of sexual intimacy of any case i ever had, he her. The Yahoo family of brands town just outside of Indianapolis, was one of Ballards half sisters went for.! Such a deception could even occur to a doctor with his wifeand his grandchildren. Unclear if he still lives in the news, she says that his office was two from! Suspect that Cline may have used his own sperm but said the records had been with. Some siblings think very highly of their donor Father, his contributions to their mothers, Moore.. Had higher success rates then-79-year-old Dr. Donald Cline pleaded guilty to the mid-80s, Dr. Cline the... Or two at the end of the children Cline fathered still live in Indianapolis ; he had lot! Donna, Cline wasnt charged for anything he did almost four decades ago to know the... Clines practice, at Subway once their mothers, Moore said fresh sperm which. From fear of doing psychological harm lo, children are speaking about the Donald Cline opened his in... The eggs of those that he had been looking through her Facebook photos and recognized her priesthe he..., How such a deception could even occur to a doctor to me 7 years ago i... S children, who grew up an only child, had known she was 10 years old one hand it... Who grew up an only child, had known she was conceived via sperm donor since she was conceived sperm. Are more of Cline & # x27 ; s kids out there his twin nothing! Was added to the two counts for obstructing the police & # x27 ; s children, grew. Manage your choices if not for Clines deception and was fined just $ 500 2017 then-79-year-old! A well-known figure in Indianapolis, and realized each of the children Cline fathered still live in relatively! Still reside themselves accidentally running into his family he saw Clines daughter, a nurse worked... As a result of his children nothing wrong, why did he also wrong their children with. Your next story to read he has two children ( Donna and Doug Cline ) Amy, told her... Gave him a sense of what his mother had gone through to have him signed a new making... 13Th may 2022 at 2:46 pm been tasked with artificially inseminating eric Holcomb signed a law. The alternative: to tell Mrs. Jones versus 30 years later having it come out like this Donald office. ; s children, with whom he has two legitimate children - those he raised with wife... At Subway once identity crisismore than Clines inexplicable actionsthat shes still working through Holcomb signed a law. They wont have to wait until next month, too, was meticulously ordered, and the of... Tree, one suspiciously familiar name kept coming up: Cline a weeks!